| Business | Phone |
| Allstate Insurance 37 Public Sq, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 392-2101 |
| American Family Insurance 20 E Washington St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 398-9601 |
| American Family Insurance 266 E Broadway St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 835-7849 |
| American Integrity 13 Public Sq, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 392-8876 |
| Witkemper Insurance Group Svc 2406 E State Road 44, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 398-9797 |
| Assurance/Nationwide Ins Co 1505 S Harrison St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 398-9645 |
| Benedict Insurance 1628 S Miller St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 398-8679 |
| Brooks Insurance 200 E Jackson St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 392-9454 |
| Bus & Prof Financial Svc Inc 406 S Harrison St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 392-4480 |
| Shelter Insurance 701 N Harrison St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 398-2886 |
| State Farm Insurance 307 S Harrison St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 392-2330 |
| State Farm Insurance 308 N Harrison St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 392-4107 |
| Cousins Insurance 45 W Washington St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 392-2275 |
| Duffy-Warble Ins 15 Public Sq, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 398-4156 |
| Ray F Breedlove Inc 705 E State Road 44, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 398-6724 |
| Farm Bureau Insurance 2915 E State Road 44, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 392-2501 |
| Olinger Insurance 420 S Harrison St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 398-8936 |
| Glasco Insurance 220 E Franklin St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 392-4593 |
| Glasco Insurance & Invest 1431 E Lawndale Dr, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 392-1923 |
| Nolley Insurance Svc 25 Public Sq # 100, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 398-2392 |
| Nolley Insurance Svc 63 E Washington St, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 398-2392 |
| Malcolm Ramsey Insurance 22 W Washington St # 100, Shelbyville 46176 | (317) 398-9601 |