| Business | Phone |
| American Family Insurance 1506 Washington St, Algoma 54201 | (920) 487-5590 |
| Northeastern Mutual Insurance 515 1st St, Algoma 54201 | (920) 487-5954 |
| Weber Insurance 225 Steele St, Algoma 54201 | (920) 487-3435 |
| State Farm Insurance 413 Steele St, Algoma 54201 | (920) 487-3553 |